Samantha smiled quickly, then softened it. She got up and moved to the bed, sitting back against the headboard and making space. Lily paused by the mattress, feeling absurd, and then climbed up and sat where Samantha wanted, because it seemed marginally less absurd than standing in the middle of the room refusing to.
She knew, settling in, that she should not have.
Samantha's legs came to either side of hers, warm and solid, and the whole length of her was there at Lily's back. When Lily leaned into it - carefully, testing it - there was a chest against her shoulders and a steady breath at her ear, and after a moment, two arms that came around her and closed. Slowly. Giving her time to refuse them. Refusing was exactly the thing she failed to do.
So she was held. Again. As she had been that morning, waking; as she had been an hour ago in the chair, with the brush going through her hair and her defences going soft against her will.
This was not what roommates did. It was not what friends did either, whatever pretty word Samantha might later find to dress it in. Lily had known that this morning, and known it through the hour with the brush, and allowed it anyway - one small thing and then the next, none of them a decision on its own, each small enough to wave through without alarm, and all of them together carrying her exactly here: sitting in between another woman's knees, held, by a girl who had made a careful study of how to hold her.
She had learned a very long time ago that the trouble with letting small things through was that they did not stay small. They gathered. They took on a shape. And one evening, you looked up from the middle of them and found the shape had a name - a name you had been at great pains never once to say.
The bed dipped softly beneath them. The room had gone quiet with the hour's lateness. For a while, neither of them spoke, and Lily lay still inside the warmth, and did not trust it, and did not leave it either, which was the worst of the available options.
Then Samantha said, in a low voice meant only for Lily, "Since we are being honest."
Lily felt the change in her. Some of the teasing brightness had gone out of her - not all of it, Samantha was too much herself for that, but enough that what remained had an unfamiliar carefulness to it. Lily had learned, over a good deal of living, to be wary of exactly that carefulness. It was the tone people used when they meant to hand you something and then watch to see what you would do with it.
"And," Samantha added, with a thread of rueful humour, "since now you cannot see my face."
Lily blinked.
There was colour in Samantha's voice. Not much, but enough that Lily understood - with a small, treacherous warmth she did her best to ignore - that Samantha was blushing.
"What is it?" Lily asked quietly.
"I would like to say a few things. Properly." A dry, small laugh. "And I would rather say them while you cannot see my face."
"That seems cowardly."
"Yes," Samantha said. "I know. Let me be a coward for a few minutes. I will go back to being unbearable later."
Lily said nothing. She was already on her guard, just a little. It was like standing at the top of a dark staircase, not because there was anything to fear yet, but because a fall could happen.
Samantha's arms tightened a little, more from nerves than from any wish to keep her.
"First," she said. "I am sorry."
"For what?"
"For pushing you." Her cheek brushed Lily's hair. "For making everything go so quickly. For..." A humourless breath. "For behaving as though being very sure of myself excused all of it."
Lily did not answer. It was, unfortunately, an accurate account of things.
"I crowd you. I know that I do. I prod, and tempt, and lean on every reaction you let slip, and I tell myself the whole time that it is only play." Samantha's voice dropped. "I suppose even a perfect and noble creature such as myself can turn out to be frightened."
The joke was there, laid neatly over the top. But the thing underneath it was not a joke, and they both knew it, and for once, Lily did not reach for the opening.
"I am scared," Samantha said.
Its plainness made Lily go very still.
"I am scared," Samantha said again, more quietly, "that you will run. That if I give you enough room, you will decide some ordinary morning that leaving is simpler than staying, and be gone before I have woken. I want to matter enough to keep you here." Her arms drew Lily a fraction closer. "You have looked, more than once, as though the whole academy were a door you were already halfway through. Even now. Even here, with my arms round you, some part of you is counting the way out."
Lily stared at the coverlet over her knees.
It was true, and it was unkind of Samantha to have seen it so exactly, and there was no honest way to say otherwise. So she said nothing, which was its own kind of yes.
"So, yes," Samantha went on, gentler, "part of what I have been doing is trying to tangle you up in it. Give you reasons. Make staying feel like the better of the two. I want to be the reason you choose to stay, not simply the place you happen to be. Not because a word of what I said to you was false - none of it was ever a game, Lily, not once - but because I hoped that if you let yourself feel how much I want you here, you might come round to wanting to be here yourself."
And there it was, Lily thought, the whole of it, said out loud and without any armour on.
She could feel Samantha's heart going against her back. Fast. Truly fast.
It moved her more than she wished it to. That was the danger in it. Not the words, which she could have argued with all night; the heartbeat, which she could not. The composed, impossible Samantha, who won every exchange in every corridor and never once let it show that anything cost her - that same girl was sitting in the dark with her arms full of a woman who kept trying to leave, saying the frightened, true thing anyway, her pulse going quick enough to count against Lily's spine.
Samantha swallowed.
"When you told me before that it was unfair of me to wait for you..." She paused. "Perhaps it is. But it feels more unfair that I want you near me in spite of everything you carry - in spite of not knowing how much of your fear is of me, and how much of it is further away than anything I could ever reach. In spite of knowing I cannot simply ask you for certainty and have it put in my hand. I want you here anyway, and I do not know how to want that less."
Lily's throat tightened. She said nothing because there was nothing she could safely say without giving away more than she meant to.
Samantha's chin came to rest, lightly, against her shoulder. "And earlier today - when you asked whether I had any ulterior motives - there was one more that I did not give you."
Lily's fingers tensed in her lap.
"I hoped," Samantha said, carefully now, choosing a word at a time, "that if I did this honestly - cared for you like this, and told you plainly what I meant by it - and you found that it was good and not frightening - then perhaps you might want it again. Not every day." A little warmth crept back in deliberately, easing its weight. "I am not so unreasonable as that. Your poor heart would give out entirely from the strain."
Lily made a small, involuntary sound, somewhere between protest and mortification.
"But once in a week, perhaps," Samantha said, into her hair. "A Saturday. I would look after you a little because I want to. Dote on you properly. And the rest of the week I would behave myself, to whatever impossible standard you cared to set."
"My standards are excellent," Lily muttered, because it was easier than any of the rest of it.
"They are tyrannical," Samantha said automatically. And then, letting the reflex fall away, gentling: "But I mean it. Every part. Not the once-a-week alone. The whole of it."
Her heartbeat had not slowed. If anything, it had gone quicker, there against Lily's back, and it was the heartbeat and not the words that undid her. Samantha meant it. She meant all of it, and she was frightened, and she had said so out loud, which made two frightened people in one small bed.
That was when Lily's own fear arrived - properly, cold, and late.
Until tonight, she had been able to tell herself a comfortable story. That this was a bright, certain girl amusing herself with a difficult roommate. That the teasing was only teasing. That Lily permitted it the way one permits weather, since there was no sense in fighting a thing that would pass on its own. But a girl who set aside a whole day of the week for you was not the weather. A girl whose heart went like that beneath your spine was not passing the time. Somewhere in the last handful of days, Lily had let a great many small things through the gate - the corridors, the names, the brush, the waking in her arms this morning, and now this - and not one of them had felt like a decision as she let it by, and all of them together had carried her here.
She should not be here. She should never once have let herself come to be here.
And the old instinct came up with the thought, the one that had never yet failed her in all the long practice of it: to be up, and dressed, and gone. To take the fright the way she had always taken it - by removing the thing that caused it, which in this case was herself.
Lily moved to rise.
Samantha's arms did not let her go.
They did not clamp down - nothing so crude, nothing she could have turned into anger and used - but they stayed, and Samantha's voice came quick and low against her hair. "Don't. Not yet. A moment more. Only a moment."
"Samantha. Let go of me."
"I know that voice." An unsteady breath, a poor attempt at lightness, lay over the top of it. "That is the voice of a woman about to be terribly sensible of me. Give me one moment before you are sensible. Please."
And here was the shameful truth of it - she could have made her let go. She was not, in the end, trapped. One word she meant, one motion with any force behind it, and she would have been out of the arms and off the bed, and Samantha would not have chased her across the room. She knew that as surely as she knew her own name. And knowing it, she also knew she was choosing to stay.
"This has gone too far," she said, and it came out harder than she meant it to, because underneath it, she was afraid, and fear in Lily had always come out wearing the shape of cold. "All of it. The names. This. The whole ridiculous evening. I have let it happen a piece at a time, and I should not have let any of it. It was careless of me."
She felt the small flinch go through Samantha - there, then quickly hidden - and disliked how well she had aimed.
"Careless," Samantha repeated, low.
"Yes."
For a moment, Samantha said nothing. Then her arms tightened - not to hold her down, only to hold on - and when she spoke, there was something raw underneath the lightness now, nothing sensible left in it at all. The easy tone had gone, and in its place was the first plain edge of hurt.
"Then let it have been careless," she said. "I never once asked you to be careful with me. I am asking you not to tear the whole of it up in a single motion because it has frightened you - and it has, I can feel that it has; you have gone hard all over like a thing bracing to be struck."
That was too near. Far too near the bone.
"You think I do not know what this is?" Samantha pressed on, faster now, the words coming the way a child's do when it argues against being sent to bed. "I know exactly what it is. I know that it is one-sided. You told me so plainly, more than once, that you cannot give me the thing I want of you - and I heard you every time, and I am still here, still asking, because I would rather have a little of you and feel it hurt than have none of you at all and call the difference wisdom." A rough breath, close to coming apart. "There. That is the whole ugly truth of me, since it is a night for those. I want this, and I am too selfish to let you go cleanly. I would sooner be hurt beside you than be sensible without you."
Lily sat with that, her own heart loud now, and found she had no ready answer to it.
"So I am not asking for everything." Samantha steadied her voice by sheer will. "I know I cannot have everything. I am asking for one day out of seven. A Saturday. I look after you, and you let me, and neither of us calls it a single thing beyond that. You get to be cared for, which you will not otherwise permit in this life. I get to care for you, which seems to be all I want to do lately. And it means nothing - because we will both agree, out loud, in words, that it means nothing." A small laugh broke apart in the middle of it. "A poor bargain. But an honest one, in that at least."
The lightness of it was so carefully built that Lily could hear precisely what it was holding up.
Because of course it meant something. That was the entire reason for the pretending. And Samantha - sixteen years old, and clever, and plainly frightened - had gone and found her own way to the very defence Lily had spent a lifetime perfecting: that if you never give a thing its name, you can go on telling yourself you have not truly got it, and so cannot truly lose it.
It ought to have made refusing easier to see the trap laid so plainly.
It did the opposite. Instead of making refusal easier, it made Lily feel the full weight of what she was refusing.
Lily shut her eyes. When she spoke, there was no cold left in it - the cold had done its work and failed, and what lay underneath was only tired, and careful, and older than she let anyone see.
"You should not want this," she said. "Not from me. I am telling you as a kindness, though I am aware it will not sound like one."
"Then do not dress it as a kindness. Only say it."
"Very well." She drew a breath that shook more than she would have liked. "I have cared for people before. More of them than I will ever tell you about. I know how it begins, and how it goes on, and how it ends, and what is left standing in the room afterwards - and so I closed the part of me that does that, and I have kept it closed a very long time." Her voice caught, and she let it catch, because Samantha had earned the truth, including the catch. "And the honest thing - the one I am trying to say to you badly - is that I no longer know whether it will open. I may be gentle with you. I may reach for you without meaning to. But that is not the same as being able to give you what you are hoping for, and I cannot promise you that I am. If I say yes to your Saturday, I let you hope on the strength of a thing I am not sure I possess - and that is the real unkindness in it. Not that I feel too little for you. That I do not know what I have left to give, and I mean to let you wager on it regardless."
For a long moment, Samantha did not speak.
Then, stubborn to the last, and quieter than before: "I know who I want it from."
"You do not yet know the price of a sentence like that one."
"Then let it cost me." There was no doubt in her voice. "I have decided. You keep trying to make the decision for me, to spare me, and I am telling you it is mine, and I have already made it. Stop protecting me from a thing I have chosen with my eyes open."
And there, Lily thought, was the whole trouble with the young: that they said such things as though wanting a thing badly enough could make it safe. As though a decision, taken bravely enough, could not still turn out to have been a mistake.
And yet she did not say no.
She reached instead, the way she always did, for the smallest way to hold a large thing. A Saturday. One evening in seven, agreed on beforehand, the rest of the week left ordinary - or as ordinary as anything between the two of them had ever managed to be. Being looked after, once a week. Those were small enough words. She could pick them up and turn them over and set them back down, and nothing broke in her hands. The other words - the ones that had a weight to them, the ones she had spent her whole life refusing to say over any living person - she left lying where they were. Unsaid. And therefore, by the only logic that had ever kept her upright, untrue.
It was the oldest trick she owned. She noticed, distantly, that tonight she was turning it the wrong way round - not to talk herself out of a thing, as she had done a thousand times, but into one. That was new. She suspected it was also worse, and that the worst of it was how much she wanted it anyway.
"If I agree to this," she said at last, "it is on terms. And you will hear all of them before you allow yourself to look so pleased."
She felt the change in Samantha at once, behind her - the caught breath, the visible effort not to seem glad too soon.
"Name them."
"You ask. Every time. There is no standing arrangement I am simply subject to from now on; there is your asking, and my answering, each Saturday as it comes, and no Saturday owed in advance."
"Yes."
"And I may refuse. Every time, for any reason or none, and you will not make me pay for the refusal - not with sulking, not with a wounded quiet, not with any of the small punishments people reach for when they have been told no and disliked it."
"No," Samantha said. "I would not. I understand."
"It stops the instant I say stop. Not when you have finished the thought. Not at some convenient pause. The instant."
"The instant," Samantha agreed.
Lily drew a breath. This was the one that mattered, and the hardest to say without letting Samantha hear precisely why it mattered so much. "And it does not creep. You will not turn the ordinary days into quiet versions of it and tell yourself they do not count. A Saturday is a Saturday. The rest of the week, I am your roommate and nothing softer, and you will not go hunting for excuses to blur the edge of the thing."
There was a pause - only the briefest, a single heartbeat too long.
"Samantha."
"I heard you," Samantha said, and this time it came slower, and cost her something to say. "No blurring. I will keep the edge sharp, since you need it sharp."
"I do."
"I know that you do."
"And the names." Lily's jaw tightened; this was the other cost, the one she had let through that very morning without stopping to count it, and meant now to take a part of it back. "In private, if you must, and rarely. Not as a habit. Never, anywhere they might be overheard. I gave you more room there than was wise. I am taking some of it back tonight."
Something in Samantha fell silent then, clearly hurt, no matter how much she tried to hide it. "In private," she said, her voice softer than before. "Rarely. All right." She didn't argue or try to reclaim any ground, and she kept a smile in her voice even as she let it go. That was a small kindness, and it hurt a little, too.
"And the last." Lily's voice dropped. "When I tell you that it is nothing, you will let it be nothing. You will not sit across from me on a Saturday with meaning all over your face. You will not make me say the true thing by leaving a silence shaped exactly like it and waiting for me to fill it in. Even when we both know better. Especially then."
The pause lasted even longer this time, and in that silence, Lily realised exactly what she was asking. She wanted Samantha to agree, right now, to help her keep lying to both of them. More than that, she needed help because she didn't trust herself to keep the lie on her own.
She realized, just a bit too late, what she had admitted. By asking Samantha to help her pretend it was nothing, she had shown it was actually something worth lying about. Samantha understood that, and that was why it comforted her more than any of the takeaways had wounded her.
"Yes," she said quietly. Her smile returned, warmer now and unhurried. "I will let it be nothing."
Lily nodded once. She felt the agreement settle over them, quiet and complete, like a contract written in a language neither of them wanted to put into simpler words.
For a while, Samantha said nothing at all. She only held her, and Lily could feel the gladness in her, kept deliberately small, folded down tight - as though Samantha too understood that if it were allowed to swell to its full size it might frighten the whole fragile arrangement off before morning, and that she was trying to keep herself gentle enough to be allowed to stay.
"Thank you," Samantha said at last - and for once there was nothing forced in it, only the two plain words.
"Do not thank me." Lily kept her eyes on the middle distance. "I am not at all certain I have done you a kindness. I rather think I have done you a slow harm and let you put your name to it."
"Let me be the judge of my own harms." A breath, warm against her hair. "I know what you believe you have handed me. Something that will only cost me, later, once I have grown too used to it to give it back. Perhaps you are right. I have thought about it too - I am not a child in every aspect. I would still rather have it than not have it, because I want this enough to accept the cost."
Lily said nothing. There was nothing useful to say to a person who had looked at the sea, and understood the cold of it, and chosen to wade in anyway.
After a while, she spoke anyway. It was the truth, and Samantha had shown more courage with her honesty tonight than Lily had in a long time. That deserved something real in return. The bargain had already changed her, and she could not keep pretending otherwise.
"For whatever it is worth to you," she said, "if I had truly meant to disappear, I would already be gone. I have had the practice. I do not, as a rule, linger anywhere I mean to leave."
Samantha's arms tightened, so suddenly that Lily nearly lost the rest of her breath - not painfully, only with the whole quiet force of what had not been said.
"That," Samantha managed, rough at the edges, "is a cruel sort of comfort to offer a person."
"It is the only sort I keep in the house," Lily said, with a dry flicker of amusement. "You may take it or leave it."
"I will take it." A pause. "I will take anything at all you are careless enough to leave lying about."
"That is precisely the difficulty."
But she said it without any heat, and she did not move away, and for a long while after that, neither of them moved much at all. Samantha held her, and Lily let herself be held, and the two of them, by unspoken and mutual agreement, did not give the quiet between them a name.
For several heartbeats after that, Samantha said nothing. Then Lily felt her gather herself - the particular stillness of a person working up to a thing - and braced, mildly, for whatever it turned out to be.
"There is one more thing," Samantha said. Her voice had gone careful in a new way, close to shy - an unfamiliar note in a girl so rarely at a loss for anything to say. "Since it is, apparently, my Saturday to spend. What little of it is left." A breath. "Could we sleep together?"
Lily went absolutely rigid.
"...not like that," Samantha corrected at once, the composure fraying at the edges in a way Lily had almost never heard from her, "obviously not like that. I do not mean that. The beds. I mean our beds, beside each other. They are half the way there already; they are only across a stupid little strip of floor..." She abandoned dignity altogether for a moment. "I am making an appalling mess of this."
"You are," Lily agreed, and was faintly ashamed of how much steadier it made her feel to hear the unshakeable Samantha shake.
Samantha breathed out and found the plainer version of it. "The beds. Moved together. For comfort only - in case the nights turn bad, so that someone is within reach when they do. That is all it would be."
Lily knew the shape of the excuse for exactly what it was. So, she was fairly sure, did Samantha. Neither of them reached out to touch it - which was, she supposed, how the whole of it was going to work from here: the two of them holding true things at arm's length and agreeing, very politely, to admire the wrapping instead.
She might have refused. It would have been the consistent thing, after everything she had just spent so much effort saying. But she thought, against her will, of waking that morning - of the disorientation of it, and then the arms, and then the strange discovery that the first thing she felt on surfacing had not, for once, been the need to be somewhere else. She thought of how seldom, across a long and careful stretch of them, the nights had been anything but a thing to be got through alone. And she found the wanting in her had gone louder than the fear now, and a good deal more stubborn.
"Beside each other, and no further than that. I will not wake to find that your notion of 'beside' has quietly narrowed to one pillow, and if I move beds back one morning without a word to you, you will not remark on it, or look wounded, or make a study of my reasons."
"I will not," Samantha said, and had the grace not to sound triumphant - though Lily could feel what it cost her.
"Then yes." A pause. And then the smaller, truer thing, given because it was owed, and because she had run clean out of the strength to keep withholding it. "Yes, Sam."
She rarely gave that name, and when she did, it struck deep, touching the part of Samantha where everything real between them lived. Lily felt her last bit of composure slip away. She just breathed once, unevenly, against Lily's hair, held her, and asked for nothing more.
After that, they didn't say much. Everything important had already been spoken, and what was left didn't need words. Both of them seemed to know that saying more might disturb what they had worked so hard to leave unresolved.
Moving the beds wasn't complicated. They stood against opposite walls with empty floor between them. Samantha dragged her bed over to Lily's side by herself, refusing help, while Lily just stood there holding a pillow she didn't really need. It felt a bit awkward, but Lily was glad for how normal it was. Being close to Samantha was easier when she could blame it on the bed frame.
When they finished, with the beds pushed together and the lamps dimmed, the room felt softer and more changed than she expected.
She lay down, now so close that there was no empty space between them, and realised how different it felt. For the first time in a long while, she was aware of another person in the room and did not brace against it.
She listened to Samantha getting comfortable - the soft sound of the blanket, the quiet noise as she turned onto her side facing Lily. Then her breathing, slow and real, was near enough that either of them could have reached out and touched, if they had dared.
It should have felt strange. It did, a little, at first - strange the way any unfamiliar kindness was, too bright at its edges, difficult to trust, a thing she kept half expecting to be snatched back the moment she relaxed enough to want it.
Then Samantha's voice came out of the dark, very quiet. "Goodnight, Lily."
Lily lay still for a while, staring up into the darkness, feeling the long weight of the day finally settle over her: the chair, the brush, the confession, the bargain, and now this.
"Goodnight, Sam," she replied after a moment, her quiet voice carrying more than just the words.
Nothing more was needed, and nothing more was given.
After that, there was only the sound of breathing.
Lily had slept alone for as long as she could remember. Even now, in that loose and unguarded time before real sleep, when the mind allowed things it would never admit when awake, she felt the difference clearly. She let herself feel it and didn't try to name it.
It was warm. It was an arrangement. It was two beds moved closer, and it was Sam asking for more than just warmth, and Lily letting herself hope for that. That much she could hold without fear. The rest she set aside for another night, one where she might have more courage, knowing there would be a reckoning for it someday. Sam would pay her share for hoping, and Lily would pay hers. Lily had promised herself, more times than she could count, that she would never let warmth reach her again, but she had chosen to lie within its reach anyway, eyes wide open. In the end, both of them did. Neither was spared.
But that was far off. The room was warm, and the breathing next to her was steady and real.
Tonight, she let it be.
ns216.73.216.67da2
and then Add to home screen.